Two of my subjects at uni, International Studies and Anthropology, are both focusing on the topic of 'Globalisation' this semester. Specifically, they are focusing on the spread of consumerism and the Western attitude that is dominant over the globe.
For both subjects, we watch a weekly video on the spread of consumerism as a major attitude amongst world cultures, and how it is overriding past values. It is sad to see how money/utility/material oriented we are as a society. For instance, in a supposed bid to eliminate the widespread branding of everything in society... Disney branded itself a town. Nothing in the town is a brand name... but it's owned by a brand name. The place is called Celebration, Florida. How crazyfull is that? If you want to investigate... the town's website is here, and the Wikipedia page (I love you Wikipedia) is here. Brands have not only extended their range.. they've created a whole new market. The people who live in Celebration are not exposed to a flood of brands - they are living under one entire one. Weird.
At Surrender, I felt compelled to buy something from a stand. It was the Klong Toey stand - a collection of bracelets, necklaces and other jewellery made by men and women under fair trade principles, with the profits going towards helping improve their quality of life. Klong Toey is a desperately poor slum in Hong Kong.
So. I wanted to go buy something. BUT I asked Simon this: "Was it because I genuinely wanted to help give money or just because I was a consumer and wanted to gain?" The answer is both. I wanted to do both.
For the record, I didn't buy anything, but it led to Sime and I discussing how even Christian culture is full of consumerism. Christian shops are a market of their own, as is Christian music and clothing and even Bibles. Even church itself can be consumed. Some go to church for their weekly dose of Christianity and feeling like a 'good person' (which is rubbish), and then they have consumed for the week and go back to other things. I am ashamed to say I do too on occasion. Used to much more than I do now.
I am not here to say that buying Christian goods is all bad. They have mostly a good message, and can help people connect with each other and with God. It is merely an observation of how much our society is about consumption and gain, rather than giving and sharing. Even Christians, who are not better people, but who often say they believe in the calling to rebel against the norm; to be real, true, God-like representatives in community; to be radicals against the injustices of society. So this is not a diatribe against Christian goods. No. This is saying that there are those out there who are in need. Every single day. And whilst we might see them on the tv one day, or read about them in the odd magazine, they are always in it. The tv goes off, but they stay in poverty... while we are off buying things and spending more money than we need to. We might even be in a Christian shop.
How to change the attitude of those with the power to help change the lives of those in need? I don't know for sure. But I'm not going to be like those people at uni who are ridiculously negative - "It's already screwed up, so why bother even trying?" or, trying to be intellectual, "Globalism might be able to help fix things, but really... it was Globalism that screwed it up in the first place." (Insert smug smile.)
I'll still try to do something. Anything. It's always better than nothing.
Ramble over.
12 years ago
How do I respond to something like that? How can I honestly say that I will try and go away from the consumerism that is ever present? This fight away from consumerism is so great as it surrounds us and ridiculously is in our church as well.
ReplyDeleteI am terrible with my consumerism and I know it. How do you know what your first step is away from consumerism?
It is fantastic that you are thinking about it. Continue to think about the issues which are in our world. You are an awesome person so intouch with what is happening around us. Keep up the great work.
You cannot immediately eliminate consumerism. But you can take little steps to be smarter, and know what you are consuming..and even who got consumed by the production of it.
ReplyDeleteI think we do know what our first step is. There are lots of first steps. Not buying that cup of coffee, not buying that new shirt, not spending that money on rubbish.
I am terrible, as I do spend money carelessly sometimes. I am not saying, "Don't spend," or that you can't spend a little on yourself sometimes, but not all the time. And not hugely. Argh, I can feel an argument coming just from what I wrote then.
Thanks for the kind words.
We are born into a community of consumption. I once heard someone say that "unless you're a farmer, then you're a consumer, so consume wisely". This says to me that we need to make wise choices about the things we consume/purchase. It's worth finding out how the products you buy are produced; are the workers exploited in some way?; do the local producers get a fair deal? Now, the odds are that if you're buying "branded" products then someone is getting screwed somewhere along the line (I know it's cynical, but that appears to be what is happening). Ethical purchases are important and just because it’s a “Christian” product don’t assume you need it, or your life will be better off with it. Don't get sucked by our marketing giants, they just want your $$$...gee, I am agitated today :)
ReplyDeleteConsumerism is such a big part of our western society, yes. I struggle with it all the time, as in, I often fall victim to it. Like Simon said, it is something we can cannot avoid, so what we need to do is simply try and be conscious of what it is we are consuming. This, too, is hard. Argh! Hardships!
ReplyDeleteWe need to invent anti-consumerism juice, so that when you pour it on things, consumerism is gone. Ok, let's get together and make this juice sometime. Tonight? Yes.
I've been struggling heaps recently with the materialism/consumerism thing. It's something that's been coming up a lot at YITS. How do we, as Christians, purchase ethically and still manage to have everything we need? I won't write everything i'm thinking or this comment will go for pages..
ReplyDeleteA horrible statistic from one of my favourite lecturers: If Christians wordlwide stopped buying Christian merchandise for one year, that money would more than cancel out third world debt.
What is necessary? And how do we decide what we buy and what we don't? and is ignorance an excuse?
Good blog, Ben. Very challenging
Sime: It is very hard to find that ethical way of living. I think it's so difficult to remove yourself from that society, and that if you did remove yourself, you remove yourself also from the opportunity to help others live at least a little more ethically.
ReplyDeleteI think you accept you are always going to be a consumer, try to live as ethically as possible, and in do something to help make things fairer for those getting screwed over.
Jono: We both struggle, like your cafeteria visits, or our KFC bills from last year ha!
Your anti-consumerism juice sounds good... but to use it people would have to buy it. Would it be made fairly with proper working conditions and pay?
Until that can be invented... we may as well face that there are hardships, but not let that stop us doing something useful.
Kyla: That is a horrible statistic. Disgusting, but there is many more such things. Like the amount America spends on foreign aid is the same as the pornography industry. Wack? Yes.
Ignorance is not an excuse. We should know, make an effort to learn, to know even just a little bit. Thank you.
Kyla: HOLY CRAP!! They were the first words to enter my mind when I read your stat! That doesn't give me a lot of hope for assisting with 3rd world poverty when you read something like that. But, we must keep on trying, keep on being the prophets of dissent, and pointing out the injustice.
ReplyDeletePeace
Sime
Sime: "Holy Crap" made me laugh lots. And you didn't even mean it at first. Ha!
ReplyDeleteBC
ReplyDeleteYeah, sometimes you just get lucky with clever puns. I was extremely lucky! :)
I had the very same problem at Surrender. I bought two books by Rob Bell in the end, one of which I am half way through, and is very good.
ReplyDeleteConsumerism is so... I don't know the words. I've always opposed it, but yet I've always been a consumer, lately getting worse. What an age we live in.
There's some video thing... I forget what it's called... 'The trouble with Paris'...
Em: I have a friend. He looks like Rob Bell. haha. I like some Noomas, but not all, I'm not sure why. Sometimes it seems to make things very simple, but that is said with me not having seen a Nooma for a few months.
ReplyDeleteI have heard about "The Trouble With Paris", but not much and am yet to see it. Let me know if you get a copy.
There is a myspace of them that has some youtube goodness. Somewhere.
ReplyDelete